asset_id	parent_asset	refresh_layer	source_path	model_or_method	job_id	seed	sha256	product_review	hypothesis_review	disposition	evidence_status
R0_ROUTINE_CONTROL	C0_FACTUAL_SOURCE	routine_context	/images/blog/ai-product-ad-creative-testing-matrix/routine-seed-1.webp	gemini-3.1-flash-image-preview	62c1ed63-57ee-411f-8c7b-1ffd8d747eb6	202608141	6eb141bba78a151c4e598ec6aecf582acf69236601595c3c71b6d6f05a4fbe7e	REVIEW	PASS	HOLD_AS_CONTROL	OBSERVED_ASSET_NOT_PERFORMANCE_WINNER
R1_GENERATED_EXECUTION	R0_ROUTINE_CONTROL	composition_camera_light	/images/blog/ecommerce-creative-fatigue-refresh-workflow/generated-execution-refresh-reject.webp	gemini-3.1-flash-image-preview	d72d4488-ea23-4557-872b-88c15e971d63	2026081801	b8b1c2f74b5bb69e1e925b1c0ea0a94f8b2e1fc74a859fb5acf338484a7bd58f	FAIL_PUMP_AND_PACKAGE_GEOMETRY_DRIFT	PASS_SAME_ROUTINE_IDEA	REJECT	OBSERVED_GENERATION_NOT_AD_PERFORMANCE
R2_APPROVED_SOURCE_LAYOUT	C0_FACTUAL_SOURCE	layout_crop_graphic_frame	/images/blog/ecommerce-creative-fatigue-refresh-workflow/approved-source-layout-refresh.webp	deterministic_layout	NA	NA	c0fb931187e9b61d0b04e8d6ff36691fd007ac42973bd3d4aa8b8cf8066ba418	PASS_SOURCE_PIXELS_PRESERVED	PASS_EXECUTION_REFRESH	ACCEPT_FOR_COPY_AND_CHANNEL_REVIEW	DETERMINISTIC_DERIVATIVE_NOT_AD_PERFORMANCE
R3_DISTINCT_ANGLE	C0_FACTUAL_SOURCE	distinctive_product_world	/images/blog/ai-product-ad-creative-testing-matrix/product-world-seed-1.webp	gemini-3.1-flash-image-preview	00f98296-ebda-4f9e-ad06-d45e0dfb73f1	NOT_RECORDED	65d0e6fe2fd2a91b772e1b83de43c98f662127b9dc8fc44cc4700eefae1ec501	REVIEW	PASS_DISTINCT_VISUAL_HYPOTHESIS	HOLD_FOR_PRODUCT_REVIEW	OBSERVED_ASSET_NOT_PERFORMANCE_WINNER